German Headscarves Ban

Court:
Domestic Courts
Country:
Germany
Status:
Active

Download Files

Download the 25-page document in English here.
278.5 KB pdf
Download the 32-page document in German here.
754.81 KB pdf
Headscarves Ban for Muslim Teachers

In 2006 several regional governments in Germany adopted laws banning teachers from wearing religious clothing or from making any ideological manifestations, supposedly to maintain neutrality and peace in the school. However, Christian and "Western" religions are explicitly exempted from the ban. This amounts to discrimination against Muslim teachers on grounds of religion, but also disproportionately affects women from ethnic minorities.

Facts

On 13 June 2006, the Regional State (Bundesland) of North-Rhine Westphalia passed a law amending the School Act of 2005. The amendment came into force on June 29, 2006. The new provisions of the law, commonly known as the “neutrality rule,” prohibit teachers from engaging in “political, religious, ideological or similar manifestations that may endanger or disturb the neutrality of the Land of NRW towards pupils or parents or the political, religious or ideological peace of the school.”

However, the law expressly exempts from this ban the “exhibition of Christian and occidental educational and cultural values or traditions.” In Germany this amendment is generally known as the “headscarf ban” law.

As a result of the law, several Muslim female teachers were prohibited from wearing their headscarves to school, and were at risk of reprimands, suspension and even dismissal. Some of them challenged the ban before German domestic courts, and two of the cases were eventually brought before the German Constitutional Court.

Open Society Justice Initiative Involvement

The Justice Initiative submitted observations to the Constitutional Court arguing that the selective ban violates European Union equality legislation as well as the prohibition on discrimination under the European Convention on Human Rights.

Arguments

European Union Law. The rule which bans religious clothing whilst protecting Christian religious clothing amounts to religious and gender discrimination in employment, contrary to both the EU Framework Directive, the EU Gender Equality Directive, as well as indirectly the EU Racial Equality Directive. The question of whether the ban is a permitted exception under EU law should be referred to the Court of Justice of the European Union in Luxembourg for a clear statement of the permissible exceptions to gender and religious discrimination.

European Convention on Human Rights. The ban which affects visible signs of Islam while permitting visible signs of Christianity and other occidental religions amounts to an unjustified difference in treatment violating Article 14 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) taken with the right to religion under Article 9 ECHR. There must be concrete evidence to objectively justify the different treatment. The Constitutional Court is invited interpret the German Basic Law in a manner that is open to international law.

Timeline

June 2006. North-Rhine Westphalia adopts an amendment to the School law prohibiting teachers from engaging in “political, religious, ideological or similar manifestations that may endanger or disturb the neutrality and peace in the school.”
2006-2009. Several cases are filed before labor courts by female Muslim teachers affected by the ban. Two anonymized cases with numbers 1 BvR 471/10 and 1 BvR 1181/10 are brought before the German Constitutional Court.
June 13, 2011. The Constitutional Court requests all German Regional States to comment on the cases and express their position and practice on this issue in their respective jurisdictions.
March 5, 2012. Justice Initiatives files its observations to the Constitutional Court.