Call the Witness: Rushdie on Roma

Salman Rushdie recently reflected on Italian prime minister Silvio Berlusconi’s comment that if Milan went to the left in the election, the city would be "flooded by Muslims and Gypsies":

The results show that the people of that city demonstrated better sense than their prime minister, and hopefully that is a sign of a change in the climate because certainly it is a horrifying thing that an entire ethnic group should be stigmatized in this country and in France and that a kind of ethnic cleansing should be carried out in Europe.

Rushdie’s testimony is one of the highlights of the Roma Pavilion, commissioned by the Open Society Foundations, at this year's Venice Biennale. His contribution is part of the Call the Witness project, which includes works of art, performances, and conversations with Roma and non-Roma artists, activists, public figures and intellectuals bearing witness to the struggles and challenges faced by Roma communities.

We live in the age of the migrant, said Rushdie, a time when more people have moved across the face of the world than ever before. The fact of migration has in large part defined modern urban life—"it is these movers who have shaken and shaped the world we live in"—an age when the majority of the inhabitants of the great cities of the world such as Bombay and New York were not born there. For a long time he has seen this as a creative force, remarking that "I myself would not be possible except in an age of migration," and that to create a hybrid world has always seemed to be an enriching thing.

But these days, he said, the subject of migration has become tinged with fear and unease. People have come to view migrant communities in their midst not as a source of enrichment, but rather to see them as other, alien and a source of sometimes fearful uncertainty: “Today there is a new fear-mongering politics which is creating a new xenophobia of the right.”

And the Roma are amongst the most vulnerable to this kind of xenophobia. Pricking the myths of rootedness and exclusivist notions of belonging that foster hostility towards the migrant other, Rushdie concluded his testimony with the following words:

To persecute groups like the Roma is to persecute our own secret selves. To criminalize an entire ethnic group is to vandalize our own secret identities …In our hearts we know that we are all misunderstood, how easy then to turn against the weakest in our midst and blame them for all our ills The Roma are in danger of becoming the scapegoats for our fears The real crime is ours, the crime of turning their life into a waking nightmare.

In another testimony, George Soros described the Roma Pavilion as more than an exhibition of works of art, but as an effort to bear witness to the poverty, alienation, and intimidation that Roma suffer today, and have suffered for centuries. Recounting the mass expulsions from France, the burning of camps and mob violence witnessed in Italy, and the killing spree of gun and bomb attacks targeting Roma settlements in Hungary which claimed nine lives, he declared that the Pavilion, "brings visitors face to face with disturbing facts and unpleasant realities. The goal is not to shock for the sake of shocking, nor to evoke sympathy, but rather to challenge us all to do something about an intolerable injustice."

This challenge is especially important in a time when neo-fascist militias and political parties are inciting hatred of Roma in Hungary and the Czech Republic, Soros said, and when political leaders disparage Roma as inferior human material, genetically disposed towards criminality, and describe Roma communities as "incubators of crime." Despite the racist hysteria, Soros asserted, there is a growing recognition, evidenced by the Decade of Roma Inclusion, that "the time has come for Roma to take their rightful place in a continent that considers itself civilized."

Soros described the many educated Roma he has encountered, increasingly confident in affirming their identity, visible in civic life, media, arts and academia, and shattering the prevailing stereotypes, as the "harbingers of a better future." Unfortunately they are a tiny minority of Europe’s 10-12 million Roma. He warned that while there is a clearly visible solution, the problem is actually getting larger, and concluded his testimony with the message:  “We know what needs to be done, we just need to do it on a larger scale.”

Robert Kushen, director of the European Roma Rights Centre, in the opening remarks to his testimony said that it seemed presumptuous for him as a "nice Jewish boy from New Jersey" to bear witness on Roma, as his experience was by definition derivative. Taking advantage of this, he made his testimony derivative and gathered the quotes of others to shine a light on what shapes contemporary politics, and at the same time, give poetic voice to the desire for a very different world. The sources spanned centuries to include politicians and poets, racist rants from blog posts, anti-Roma graffiti, excerpts from old edicts of banishment to new provisions for mass deportations of Roma.

Kushen's testimony gave voice to Roma from all walks of life, to their aspirations, resilience, and pride in the face of hostility and humiliation. One highlight of the testimony was a quiz: "Who is the Nazi?" Interspersed, in chilling accord with, and virtually indistinguishable from utterances by 21st-century prime ministers and prominent politicians was a quote from Heinrich Himmler.

The Roma Pavilion was described in the Dutch daily NRC as sending "the most powerful signal to the others that the national pavilions in Giardini belong to the story of the past." It has also garnered praise in the other main Dutch daily newspaper, Volkskrant, for its clear artistic and political statement: "Here one could breathe in the air of openness and tolerance. A perfect connection to the general theme of the Biennale: Illuminations."

5 Comments

The concept of human migration is as old as history itself. Hence, the modern Man is a direct result of the hybrid Person born of such many human interactions!

A denial of the above submission is like asserting an unknown ancestry-when it is only the Mother, perhaps, that knows the real truth about such!

Xenophobic tendencies are born out of historical fallacies-like the fallacy of purity and the superhuman status.

The modern civilisation, as we know it, is actually a direct output of such human migrations-if we tend to stigmatise migrant populations why don't we as well disclaim the very modern civilisation which we are its heirs!

Human migration is opportunity to have a society embracing human experiences, breaking down difference where harmful and building up difference in new ways, for a diverse society improves the conditions for improvement.

My family was a part of the "great migration" of the 1940s moving from South Carolina to New York City and here for five generations we've found more tolerance and the power of diversity. Yet racism still persists and we know about the tinge of "fear and unease." It's interesting to note that Isabel Wilkerson's new book, "The Warmth of Other Suns" reports more African American returning south, again in a reverse migration.

In addition, Human migration provides an enviroment that foster cross fertilisation of ideas.

Not that I have the experience of migrating myself but I benefited greatly through my interaction with migrants from other Countries-development workers.

These People came with new ideas and skills on how to work on improving the capacity of civil society organizations to perform better. I never attended fromal schooling in organisational development. But I can safely attest to it that much of what I learned informaly-in the process of such interactions, on organisational development came from expart workers in my country.

Such that today, even though I am looked upon as some sort of civil society specialist, I am really proud of the important lessons I recieved through working closely with People who were foreigners in my land.

The civil society movement that is currently benefitting from my acquired expertise is an indirect beneficiary of such interactions.

And where the civil society movement becomes a strong force to reckon with, there are significant strides realised in National development.

Give me one man who ever learned all that he knows today only from interacting with his fellow country men!

Such interactions form the very basis for mordern civilisation-hence the many learning visits to other countries conducted and the many conferences and seminars where very critical information to the survival of humankind is shared!!

Yes, it is true we are half way through the Decade of Roma Inclusion. However, to what extent is this just a title to be ticked off on a piece of paper? When I gave a talk recently about Roma culture in a school in Finland not one student or teacher knew about this. Indeed, some teachers were surprised there was a difference between Roma culture and Romania. The issue is more serious than racism. Here in Turku, European Capital of Culture 2011 there are lots of wonderful innovative human rights displays and activities. One was a woman rowing down the river, pulling a long line of shoes donated by refugees. There is not one mention of the hidden minority of Europe, the Roma, Europe's largest minority. The parallels with North American Indians and the Aboriginals of Australia are striking. Many speak out in their name, yet to find a passionate defender of human rights mention the Roma is more than rare. As a despicable racist magazine said,that will remain unmentioned due to their request, while mentioning advised hatred towards other ethnic groups: ''How many Roma have been suicide bombers? How many Roma are involved in gang warfare? Muggings? Which country, throughout history, was ever attacked or invaded by the Roma, with the intention of taking it over?

In our narrow definitions found in religion and political society we have cut ourselves off from the human miracle of life. Now we can only fear others difference rather than enjoy the new company. XXTT

Add your voice