Failing to Heal: Hunger Strikes in Guantánamo and the Role of Medical Professionals

Almost every medical school student takes an oath upon graduation based on the classic 4th century BC text named after the “father of medicine,” Hippocrates. It is worth recalling the ancient commitment to the central tenet of the classic oath regarding the sick: “I will keep them from harm and injustice.” This commitment is echoed in the contemporary international medical principle of beneficence, which mandates that the modern physician be an advocate for the patient’s interests, from the perspective of both immediate medical services and the necessary protective environment in which those services are provided.

In a recently released bipartisan and comprehensive report on detainee treatment at the detention facility in Guantánamo Bay (GTMO), Cuba, the Constitution Project’s Expert Task Force devotes a whole chapter to the spectacular failure of medical professionals in GTMO to protect detainees from harm or injustice. Beginning with the troubling reflections of U.S. Navy Capt. Albert Shimkus, the former detention center’s chief medical officer, the report demonstrates in great detail the willingness of medical personnel at GTMO to participate in a deliberate attempt to misrepresent the cruel realities in the detention facility by proffering a false reality. Capt. Shimkus’ official claim was that prisoners at GTMO “never had it so good,” with first-rate medical care and balanced nutritious meals.

Although the regular medical services provided no doubt did meet appropriate professional standards, psychologists, psychiatrists, and physicians were also actively engaged in a much darker aspect of GTMO: the often brutal interrogations of detainees. Medical professionals were complicit in torture by helping to refine practices euphemistically called “Enhanced Interrogation Techniques,” by monitoring medical “redlines” during the interrogations, and by providing interrogators and their superiors with the moral fig leaf that a doctor was monitoring the situation. Officials in charge of interrogation policy could rely on the involvement of doctors to claim that any abuses were not really all that bad. This dichotomy of conflicting responsibilities of Department of Defense medical professionals ensured a “Jekyll and Hyde” reality for detainees, which negated any real therapeutic relationship as demanded by the Hippocratic Oath and by medical ethics. The same medical professionals who monitored interrogation of detainees were also responsible for regular health care of those same people. By accepting these detrimentally opposing roles, healers could inevitably no longer be healers.

The absence of a trusting relationship between detainees and health professionals was further exacerbated by another Kafkaesque reality that GTMO detainees find themselves in—a regime of indefinite detention. Dozens of people remain in GTMO without criminal charge and with no hope of ever leaving the facility. The U.S. government has cleared for release some 86 of the 166 prisoners currently in Guantánamo, many of whom have been awaiting their freedom for many years. Physicians for Human Rights (PHR) has documented the severely detrimental health impacts this complete uncertainty and inability to determine one’s own fate has on detainees. The U.S. government knows full well that many detainees have never had any hostile intentions toward the United States, and that they should have never been held at GTMO in the first place. The only reason they are still there is the inconvenient fact that no acceptable third country is available to take them off our hands. This result is hardly surprising, given that the United States brought the detainees to GTMO despite international criticism, and U.S. lawmakers ensured that not a single one of them could be released into the United States. In recognition of the futility of a diplomatic “Mission Impossible” along the lines of, “Please take some GTMO detainees off our hands, while we in the United States will take none, thank you very much,” the office charged with the closure of GTMO was closed itself.

Imagine the combined impact of all of these factors on the detainees at GTMO. The utter desperation of being at the complete mercy of a seemingly unaccountable authority that declares one thing and does another has had deadly consequences. In acts of complete desperation, detainees have resorted to harming themselves, as is evidenced by the seven suicides and several waves of hunger strikes at GTMO.

As media reports indicate, as many as 130 prisoners could now be on a hunger strike. And what is the U.S. government’s response to this ongoing crisis? Force feeding. As experts at PHR have clearly demonstrated, force feeding can amount to torture. The international medical community has authoritatively addressed the issue of treatment of hunger strikers in the Declaration of Malta by the World Medical Association, and the U.S. government should strictly follow those guidelines and procedures. The Declaration of Malta has one important recurring theme and precondition, though, which the current system in GTMO simply cannot meet—a trusting and respectful relationship between the hunger striker and his doctor.

If the past is not to be prologue for more abuses, the current administration must do three things immediately to act responsibly during this crisis:

  1. Independent medical professionals need to have full and unfettered access to the hunger strikers, so that they can credibly implement the Malta Declaration without the practice of force feeding.
  2. The administration must immediately address the issue of indefinite detention in GTMO and elsewhere. The administration should actively find ways to repatriate or relocate those individuals cleared for release and should charge all those who are not cleared.
  3. For this purpose, the administration must immediately appoint a high-ranking government official of international stature to the currently vacant position of Special Envoy for the Closure of Guantanamo, and widely publicize this appointment at the detention facility and abroad.

13 Comments

Guantanamo is a disgrace and a stain on the American judicial system and on the US's human rights record. It should be closed AT ONCE and it is TORTURE to force-feed prisoners. Please stop this internationally renounced practice and close Gitmo once and for all.

as far as i understand taking the oath in the united states and canada has been on the decline and almost non existant in all other western civilizations(passe,but fact check with the ama members,to cumbersome a principle).
also i'm sure that any gitmo detainee that is released can easily be tracked by body mass indexing,hence the force feeding.

every part of guantanamo is wrong and the biggest 'wrong' part is barry obama, whip out that executive order pen and do your job!!! plus, pardon Bradley Manning at the same time too

It seems that the great United States is behaving like a dictatorship in a banana republic. We send drones which kill women and children, we ship people off to distant countries to be tortured, and now we are seeing the truth about Guantanamo. All pressure should be brought on the President to close such a disgraceful place. I am truly appalled - yet again!

US is not more to do with democracy, by lawless pratice and cruel attitude like toture, killing by drone. millitary intervention, intimidation, bullying , supporting zionist illegal state can be inhereted from nazi.

First the people in Guantanamo have not even been tried or convicted of being terrorists many were put there under questionable circumstances. Over half have been cleared and should be released the rest should be sent to a US MAX-SECURITY facilitay to face trial in a Civilian court and if not found guilty let go all those who were wrongully inprisonend like 99% shoud be paid some form of compensation

Release the prisoners who the government does not intend to charge. Habeus Corpus is a foundational principle of a civilized society. 11 years is too long to be in jail pending charges. We don't live long enough to sacrifice so many years for no good reason.

Force feeding those who protest this affront to the rule of law is torture. This exacerbates the cruel and unusual treatment given to these desperate prisoners.

When are you going to discuss THE TARGETEDTORTUREINDIVIDUAL IN AMERICA. I'M A GRANDMOTHER NOT A TERRORIST. I'M ALSO TARGETED IN AMERICA.(HOW SICK)!!!!

bradley manning and others, who have retained their humanity, and given up their freedom to be the voice of conscience to america's wars of profit will be heroes in time to come.

it' to bad hugo died,with a united castro and chaves regiem
the us could've been booted of the island.

Article, engaging. Not knowing the circumstances of each incarcerated at Guantanamo, these incarcerated people have "Rights;" but where those "Rights" exist is the question! Maybe the United Nations should intervene!

I believe the incarcerated in Guantanamo are cared for so well, and eat better than many people around the world, that is their torment, not torture (for their failure).

Their failure, in whatever their participation in the "war against terror," were targeted and captured and denied their destiney, and incarcerated at Guantanamo, is their torment. And, if their torment has driven them into madness to starve themselves to death; then that is their "Right." But, Americans will never let them starve themselves to death (not because of their misery), because "it's not the right thing to do. If such kindness adds to their torment and misery, so be it! But kindness is not torture (but power).

Yes, these incarcerated people at Guantanamo need a forum to resolve & reconciliate their issues of incarceration. It is not the American court system or the military courts!

If the "War on Terror" is a global matter, then the United Nations is the proper forum for these Guantanamo prisoners!

It's the United Nations that needs to act!

Respectfully submitted,
/s/
William J. Journey, Alaskabushman

The closure of the Gitmo, although an overdue noble demand, is not the real issue. The issue is to curtail and if possible to eliminate the power of powerful nations and individuals to subjugate the weak and powerless.

President Obama, promised to end the disgrace and blot on American Human Rights record but even after winning the second term, no real actions have taken place. Can some one remind President Obama to live by his own word!

Add your voice