How Do You Quantify Hope for Black Men and Boys?

When it comes to support for initiatives focused on improving life outcomes for black males in America, where should we go from here?

How do you quantify hope? I’ve been asking myself this question recently in my role leading the Open Society Campaign for Black Male Achievement. The question increasingly presses on my heart and mind during this current moment of intensified focus on the disparities facing black men and boys in America, particularly with the increased demand for evidenced-based outcomes and for lifting up what truly works.

I come in contact with leaders, young and old, every day working hard to fuel the field of black male achievement, who give me hope that lasting change is possible. This week, the Foundation Center and their BMAfunders team published a report that should provide the nation with a recipe for quantifying hope for black men and boys.

Building a Beloved Community: Strengthening the Field of Black Male Achievement is a timely resource in light of a growing chorus of national initiatives focused on improving the life outcomes of black males. Based on interviews with 50 leaders in the social, academic, government, and business sectors, Building a Beloved Community maps the landscape of work in black male achievement and offers recommendations for what it will take to strengthen the field moving forward.

The report attempts to answer the question posed in the title of its 2012 companion report, Where Do We Go From Here? Philanthropic Support for Black Men and Boys. It declares that we need to go where Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. described a generation ago as the Beloved Community—a nation fulfilling the pledge of its founding promise of “justice for all.”

About the Beloved Community, King said “we are tied together in the single garment of destiny, caught in an inescapable network of mutuality.” This notion is linked to scholar and civil rights activist Lani Guinier’s premise that black men and boys are America’s “canaries in the mine”—that the inequities they face are inextricably connected to all citizens. In fact, it was Guinier’s premise that helped convince the Open Society U.S. Programs board of directors to launch the Campaign for Black Male Achievement in 2008. Since then, we have worked with countless partners to help catalyze the emerging leaders and organizations that are depicted in the Building a Beloved Community report.

We at the campaign are thrilled to have the Foundation Center as one of our core research partners over the years. Seema Shah and Grace Sato have leaned into this mission to produce groundbreaking reports like Building a Beloved Community and launch, the central repository for all things black male achievement.

With the recent announcement of the White House’s My Brother’s Keeper Initiative, increased philanthropic engagement through the Executives’ Alliance to Expand Opportunities for Boys and Men of Color, and a groundswell of attention to this issue, there is an opportunity for change that must be pursued with a sense of urgency.

But as Darren Walker, CEO of the Ford Foundation, notes in the report, what is needed to effectively respond to this moment is “bold, courageous leadership.” And I believe that is one way to quantify hope for the field of black male achievement: supporting the many bold, courageous leaders across sectors who are working to improve the life outcomes for black men and boys. Building a Beloved Community provides us with glimpses of many such leaders.

While this report has generated a good deal of activity in just the first days of its release, the overriding message woven through it is that we must not confuse activity with progress. We have an opportunity to maximize this opportunity into lasting change. 

Geoff Canada, CEO of the Harlem Children’s Zone and one of the Open Society board members who helped launch the Campaign for Black Male Achievement, reminds us in the report’s afterword that "the barriers to success that black men face have been in plain sight for decades, so it is particularly heartening to see a movement taking shape that is specifically crafted to address these challenges and change the odds for one of the most disenfranchised populations in America. We are moving in the right direction, but we need to keep in mind that our commitment must be for the long haul." Canada’s words remind us that when it comes to the field of black male achievement, we are the leaders that we’ve been waiting for.

How do you quantify hope for black men and boys? Share your thoughts below.

Learn More:



As Mr. Canada noted in the report's afterword section, these issues have been virulently sucking the life from Black males for decades. More reports and studies won't in themselves, change the persistence of the problem's effects on our boys and men. Launching radical action programs designed to challenge these problems, along with our sustained commitment to sincerely embrace our boys' humanity will propel us to confront the systemic evils of poverty, racism, and psychological oppression feeding these problems. Militancy in our determination to confront and win is necessary. Let's-just-see-what-happens approaches are of little value -- no matter how well funded.

Men must take the leadership role of KNOWING how to capture our children's brain from birth to age twelve. We teach that awareness at

We can quantify by keeping track of those who participate in any efforts targeting them, and tracking the outcomes by f/u surveys.

Quantify hope by seeking love. Right now, the state of Black Men and Boys is ruled by fear.

Earlier in my life I would not have thought that this was something that would affect me. But now I have 3 1/2 black grandchildren and two of them are boys. They will never pass as white, and it isn't important that they do, but I am very concerned because I have read the statistics for black boys and men. I have two grandsons who have a father in prison. One father is black and the other is half Hispanic. I have spent years writing to the black man trying to keep his value as a human being first in his thoughts, so he will be able to be father to his son when he gets out. They get longer sentences and spend more time in solitary. It is hard to be granted parole. We have to care about the men inside to be able to change the next generation who grew up without their fathers. You can read about this at "My Name is Jamie. Life in Prison" at

The Common Core Initiative will ruin progressive programs that are offering hope to underprivileged groups. Despite the rhetoric that the Common Core will be good for all students, this initiative has never been field tested and there are many questions about the unintended consequences of this program and the profit driven inertia behind its implementation.

Does the Open Society Foundations support this Common Core initiative and if so, why isn't there critical analysis done on this before approving and supporting Common Core? Especially in respect to how the common core will harm programs like the one discussed in this article.

The emphasis on conformity and standardized testing, resulting in sheep and standardized curriculum to prepare for the tests seems contrary to the ideals of democracy and of a free and open society that allows creativity and innovation. Common Core is not the answer for public education and needs to be removed from our schools before zapping the zeal from learning and diminishing the hope of countless students.

How can I find help for my son who is 22 yrs. old? He's a high school graduate who got in trouble with the law and went to jail. After coming out with a different mentality, he stole from us and this is why he can't be in our home. He is now on the streets, around Lake st. and the EL.. Who, or where can I find someone to reach out to him, especially now as the cold weather is upon us. He's worth saving, but I don't know how. HELP ME PLEASE, HELP ME.

Add your voice