For Roma in France, Is Climate of Intolerance Fueling Violence?

Amid such intolerant rhetoric, should we be surprised that outright hostility to the presence of Roma in France manifests itself by violence?

Somewhere in a hospital in Paris tonight, a Roma teenager lies in a coma fighting for his life. Accounts suggest that the boy, known to us only as Darius, was accused of burglary by residents of a poverty-stricken public housing development in Pierefitte-sur-Sienne; they subsequently abducted him, beat him into a coma in a basement, and dumped his body in a shopping trolley.

President François Hollande has called the attack “unspeakable and unjustifiable,” and Prime Minister Manuel Valls also condemned the perpetrators. Le Monde, the leading French daily, characterized the attack as part of a culture of score-settling in a poor community that scorns the police. But it also saw the violence, after a new Roma group had established an encampment in the area, as the outcome of several years of failed public policy that has “perpetuated Roma poverty, and fueled a latent racism towards them in French society.”

This anti-Roma sentiment can be seen at the highest levels of French society and politics. As interior minister, Mr. Valls last year declared that “the majority [of Roma] should be delivered back to the borders. We are not here to welcome these people.” In July last year, during an eviction operation at a Roma settlement, MP Gilles Bourdouleix, of the Maine and Loire region of Western France, remarked to a journalist that “Hitler didn’t kill enough (Roma).”

Amid such intolerant rhetoric, should we be surprised that outright hostility to the presence of Roma in France manifests itself by violence?

And what are the repercussions of the mainstream political parties’ use of ethnic scapegoating? Following the European elections in May, the Front National became France’s main representation in the European Parliament, winning 25 percent of the vote.

Not everyone is silent. In October last year, schoolchildren blockaded the streets of Paris to protest the treatment of Leonarda Dibrani, a 15-year-old Roma schoolgirl. Dibrani was on a field trip when her school bus was surrounded by police and she was forcibly taken off in full view of her classmates. Her family had come to France five years ago to claim asylum, citing discrimination in their native Kosovo.

There was nobody around to defend Darius against violent mob rule last week—not his friends, not his family, and certainly not the French state. Despite President Hollande’s pledges to reverse his predecessor’s hardline approach towards Roma, evictions of settlements and deportations have increased under his tenure.

Learn More:



Thank you, Ms. Nadyenova and the ERRC for this timely response. This is a call for Roma to stand up in solidarity across Europe. Eastern European Roma NGOs have a strong voice and it is time that they speak up in solidarity to add support for the Roma in France. We are European citizens in a civil society and it is our place across all of Europe to denounce the actions of the authorities in France that have led to this situation, and to encourage them to change their course of action. For too long we have waited for our Western European allies to help improve the situation for Roma in the east, and we cannot count on them to do the job for us. We need to act together, from east to west across the EU. We cannot be timid. It is our place to Stan up, make our voice heard, and create change. There is too much silence concerning the politics of race, and we need to expose what is happening.

Thank Bill, for the words of encouragement! I do not see the solidarity yet but I hope soon to be there. Best regards, Violeta

Add your voice